Hare-Krishna.org Home

Hare Krishna News   |   Hare Krishna Philosophy   |   Hare Krishna Books   |   Puja Sponsorship   |   Online Store
Hare Krishna Menu
Yoga Basics DVD
Email Newsletter

Online Donations
Radhanatha Para-paksha

By George A. Smith | Published 12/15/2006
Category: Hare Krishna News , New Vrindavan Controversy
Article Viewed 931 Times
Rating: Unrated

asac-chastresu sajjeta
nopajiveta jivikam
vada-vadams tyajet tarkan
paksam kamca na samsrayet

Translation

Literature that is a useless waste of time -- in other words, literature without spiritual benefit -- should be rejected. One should not become a professional teacher as a means of earning one's livelihood, nor should one indulge in arguments and counter-arguments. Nor should one take shelter of any cause or faction.

Radhanatha's wonderful story strikes me as falling into this category of being a useless waste of time. It is simply an attempt at self glorification, motivated by a desire to fool people into thinking him spiritually advanced so that they will continue to support him. He is simply trying to maintain himself as a professional teacher and through his association with Kirtanananda and even ISKCON, he certainly fits himself into this last category of "should nots" that he has done and is still doing.

I never met Kirtanananda, never met the murderer of Sulocana, but I doubt that anyone of any actual spiritual advancement would have formed such a close association with these two individuals. It would simply be intolerable, for both the spiritually advanced person and the murderer and pedophile, simply for the fact that a spiritually advanced person would have no choice but to oppose such men by speaking the truth to them.

na sabham praviset prajnah
sabhya-dosan anusmaran
abruvan vibruvann ajno
narah kilbisam asnute

"A wise person should not enter an assembly if he knows the participants there are committing acts of impropriety, and if, having entered such an assembly, he fails to speak the truth, speaks falsely, or pleads ignorance, he will certainly incur sin." (Srimad Bhagavatam 10.44.10)

Had Radhanatha actually been spiritually advanced while under the shelter of these demons, he would most likely now be dead from their reactions to his having to speak the truth to them.

"Hiranyakasipu, being a demon, would always consider Lord Vishnu and His devotees to be his enemies. Therefore the word para-paksha ("on the side of the enemy") is used here. Hiranyakasipu never agreed with the words of Vishnu, or Krishna. Rather, he was angered by the intelligence of a Vaishnava." (Srimad Bhagavatam 7.5.6 Purport))

Instead of offering Kirtanananda and Tirtha the wisdom of the wise, the intelligence of a Vaisnava and the truth that one must speak in such an assembly or certainly incur sin - Radhanatha remained silent, or even supportive, and even perhaps complicit. He became para-paksha; on the side of the enemy.

According to verse 10.44.10 from Srimad Bhagavatam, Radhanatha became implicated in their sins. And what were those sins? Common men, husbands and fathers, cannot but weep when they hear of them, and these things were done to Krsna's devotees. Radhanatha has incurred the sin of the worst Vaisnava aparada many times over. He is not spiritually advanced, just the opposite, for such sins as these one is damned.

Whatever spiritual advancement Radhanatha once may have had was vanquished by his association with a molester and murderer of a devotee, and nothing except their forgiveness will save him from lifetimes in Hell with them.

That Radhanatha says he did not "like" Kirtanananda is just a feeble attempt to throw us off the scent. Many of Adolph Hitler's generals didn't like him either, but that did not save them from judgment at Nuremberg, and this will not save Radhanatha. Radhanatha did not oppose Hitler...I mean Kirtanananda, instead he at least went along with him. How far he went along with him may be behind his continued association with Sulocana's murderer. One wonders what he is continuing to support? Probably just his own skin, for if he doesn't continue to support Tirtha das, who can say what Tirtha das might know about him and choose to reveal, if he thinks that his old buddy has deserted him?


Special Offer: The Bhagavad Gita
beautifully sung on 10 Audio CDs



Now you can listen to the ancient sanskrit chants of Bhagavad Gita, sung in classical melodies by noted devotional singer Sri Vidyabhushana. Listen to all 700 verses of the Gita with a beautiful accompaniment of flute, veena, sitar, mridanga, tabla and tala. (Scroll down to listen to it online.)

Special Offer: $39.45
Regular Price: $49.45
(with free postage to anywhere in the world)


Set includes 10 audio CDs (7 CDs of sanskrit chants, 2 CDs containing english translations for the entire Bhagavad Gita, and 1 CD providing an introductory lecture on the Bhagavad Gita by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada).

Rate this article and leave a comment:
Rating: ( required ) Poor Excellent
    Your Name *:   ( required )
    Email (private) *:   ( required )
    Website:    
Please copy the characters from the image below into the text field below. Doing this helps us prevent automated submissions.
Security Code: img

No popular articles found.
No popular authors found.
Learn Sanskrit CD

Simple and clear lessons for learning Sanskrit, beginning from the very basics, up to grammar and comprehension. The complete multimedia CD-Rom for learning Sanskrit.

Just $14.95 with free
postage to anywhere
in the world.

Search Hare Krishna
Ask a Question
Do you have a spiritual question? Please write.

Audio CDs
Multimedia CDs
Malas
(Prayer Beads)
Videos and DVDs
Ayurvedic Medicine
Natural Incense
Contact Us | Bhaktivedanta Ashram | Puja Sponsorships | Charity in India |





Powered by IndiaDivine Communications